logoalt Hacker News

Noaidi • yesterday at 10:29 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

This statistic completely ignores the fact that the US externalizes its' CO2 emissions by externalizing by sending our manufacturing to other countries.

How much of China's CO2 is a result of the products Americans buy that were manufactured in China?

If we look at CO2 as a result of consumption it would tell a truer story.


Replies

rootusrootus • today at 12:39 AM

> How much of China's CO2 is a result of the products Americans buy that were manufactured in China?

Still their emissions. They could choose not to subsidize their industry in pursuit of being manufacturer for the whole world. They do not get to dodge accountability by blaming it on their customers.

belorn • yesterday at 11:48 PM

The general solution to a global market where countries chooses to have different industry regulations is to impose tariffs to compensate for the real cost of production so that external producers has the same conditions as internal ones.

On the flip side, we should not take away agency from those who choose to favor increased export industry over increased emissions. That is an active choice. Same if they allow poor employment safety or child labor. The importer of goods has some moral responsibility to buy from someone else (even if its more expensive), but the absolute majority of responsibility is on the country that actively allow such practices. Emission numbers can't be white washed by claiming that it goes to exports, as if being paid to do it means zero responsibility (a very strange notion to begin with).

hollerith • yesterday at 11:24 PM

Is that really true?

There are manufacturing processes that use a lot of energy, and the US does a lot of that (maybe more than China) because it has low energy costs.