logoalt Hacker News

Spiwux • yesterday at 6:14 AM • 5 replies • view on HN

I don't understand this post. It doesn't explain the concrete problems with grading log footage. And you can convert log footage to REC709 in a way that would give you the same result as if you'd just recorded in REC709 to begin with. At least for most established camera brands. Maybe this post is referring to grading more fringe brands that have bad/undocumented color science or don't offer proper conversion paths?

Either way it does not explain the concrete issues of recording in log. If you have a strong title like "Stop doing X" you better have some damn good arguments if you think you can tell other people what to do.


Replies

rickdeckard • yesterday at 9:03 AM

He's a colorist, stating that many videographers shoot log incorrectly and decide to defer the work to post-production, creating unnecessary complexity and bad source-material.

The plea is for filmmakers to stop following the hype, use what they are experienced with and take ownership of exposure again ("Many times a videographer will shoot log incorrectly – generally underexposed – expecting to ‘fix it in post’").

Because in his experience log doesn't add substantial value, it creates lower-quality base-material with substantial post-production work.

It makes sense. Creative work comes from decisions being taken, log means that the videographer is not deciding but is deferring the task to post-production, creating a unnecessary burden (and possibly diluting his own creativity).

➕ show 6 replies
yokoprime • yesterday at 7:00 AM

I think the message was "stop trying to fix things in post", but I too am still I bit bewildered as to why it's an issue.

➕ show 4 replies
KaiserPro • yesterday at 9:26 AM

Hmm unless something has changed, rec.709 is 8bit, so yeah if you're good you can just shoot in rec.709

But if you want to play with the colour, loosing 4bits of colour precision means you aint recovering whats in the blacks. (log supposedly allows better detail recovery in blacks, but that was for film, I don't know about digital anymore)

➕ show 2 replies
rickdeckard • yesterday at 9:13 AM

> "And you can convert log footage to REC709 in a way that would give you the same result as if you'd just recorded in REC709 to begin with"

I think beside of this extra-step in post (which comes with its own set of parameters again), that's part of his point:

The videographer didn't expose for a specific look in a scene, he didn't decide at all and postponed to post-production. This is not adding value, it's creating work.

"Many times a videographer will shoot log incorrectly – generally underexposed – expecting to ‘fix it in post’. The same issues apply to shooting in camera raw or HDR."

ryandamm • yesterday at 7:51 AM

I think what the author is trying to say is that directors of photography don’t know how to expose an image properly when they are targeting Rec709 output but shooting and monitoring in a different color space.

But this is a nontechnical article for a nontechnical audience.