logoalt Hacker News

bodeadly • yesterday at 6:30 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

A central point of this article seems to be claiming that adding a device in AD is an administrative bottleneck compared to cloud. If that is the claim, it is false. By default Authenticated Users have an "Add workstations to domain" capability (AKA ms-DS-MachineAccountQuota attribute on their account) that allows a regular user to create up to 10 machine accounts with zero admin intervention.

Machine accounts have limited rights compared to regular users. AD provides fine grained distributed policy and cert managment. After decades of emperical refinement, AD is often superior to what the cloud offers including Entra. In environments with many PCs that require centrally managed policy, AD is still relavant and probably required.

I think it is also true that there are and always will be many companies that simply cannot expose these PCs to the cloud either because they're working with data that cannot be in the cloud like legal files, finanical documents, schematics or they cannot risk being tethered to the Internet. You know that little micro PC attached to the cart in every exam room in a doctors office? There is a 99% chance it is joined to AD.


Replies

jiggawatts • yesterday at 8:07 PM

What Linux admins don’t “get” about Active Directory was the superpowers granted by its Group Policy feature.

Everyone loves to harp on about how terrible the Registry is, but that’s missing the forest for a tree.

The registry + GPO engine is a strongly typed and layered settings engine with:

Machine, Machine Policy, User, and User Policy layered on top of each other, consistently, through pretty much every native app!

More importantly, policy would apply or unapply dynamically and cleanly.

You could move a laptop to a different office and soon as it connected the wifi its set of configured printers would change, its outbound proxy could be reconfigured, etc.

More importantly: Microsoft engineers of the era put in the work of writing up thousands of settings in template files that shipped with Windows, with simple checkbox UI controls and paragraphs of descriptions in every language!

If you think your terrible “settings automation” tool is a viable alternative just ask yourself this question: does it “put the work in” or does its user have to?

➕ show 2 replies
wtch98 • yesterday at 6:57 PM

When it comes to friction in corporations it's typically policy based

It starts off easy to get stuff done, then corporate IT starts to lock down (for various reasons), then those on the edge move to new pastures where they can do work (provision a VM on prem? 50 page form passed through 12 departments. Provision the exact same VM in ec2? 3 clicks)

Eventually corporate IT decides that there needs to be governance and the cycle continues.

➕ show 2 replies
philamonster • yesterday at 8:22 PM

> You know that little micro PC attached to the cart in every exam room in a doctors office? There is a 99% chance it is joined to AD.

So are the cop cars in my city. Walked by one w/two officers in it in a supermarket parking lot last year and had to explain what a trust relationship issue is, unironically.