That model is still fairly broken, you can ask for all of the specific perms and there is still a ton of stuff that isn't covered and requires full disk access. So even if you want to use all the prompts when needed at time of action, you still cannot as a dev.
It does not have to be perfect. And really, it cannot be. There will always be corner cases. If it works in most cases, I am happy to enable full access for apps that really need it. I am not going to do it for 100 apps, and I am not going to do it if the app fits one of the cases where it does work, either.
As a developer, it’s another set of hoops to jump through. As a user, I am happy that there are some guardrails (that I can disable).