logoalt Hacker News

New Evidence Shows School Phone Bans Are Gradually Improving Test Scores

923 points • by donohoe • today at 11:45 AM • 471 comments • view on HN

Comments

robot_jesus • today at 12:46 PM

My kids (16 and 13) both attend schools that recently implemented phone bans and they love it, somewhat surprisingly. They've commented on how one of their favorite things about school is actually the social aspect. Before the ban, at lunch or study halls or recess, kids would just be on their phones and now they're laughing and goofing off, as kids should be doing.

Bonkers to me that we ever allowed this.

Oh, and for context, the kids are allowed to go to the office and check in on a message or send a text (e.g., soccer practice is canceled due to rain, can you pick me up at 4?) during any non-class period so it's still easy to communicate.

➕ show 19 replies
yorwba • today at 1:38 PM

The study https://cepr.harvard.edu/sites/g/files/omnuum9881/files/2026... finds a ≈0.01 standard-deviation difference in test scores the year lockable phone pouches are adopted, with no detectable additional difference in the following year. Certainly nothing to sneeze at from a system-wide perspective, but easily overwhelmed by other factors for any individual student.

➕ show 5 replies
vezycash • today at 2:12 PM

Everyone in the US knew phones were destroying attention spans years ago, but educational bodies and school boards punted the burden down to individual schools, teachers, and parents. Of course it failed: no single teacher or parent wants to be the bad guy and face social friction.

China just banned them outright. It's the same with companies - weak committee vs. a founder who just makes the hard call.

➕ show 4 replies
travisgriggs • today at 2:46 PM

How long before this enters the work force at various points?

My empty nester wife reentered the work force as a nurse. As one of her studies during her in hospital training she studied cell phone impacts on nursing. She’s commented how some nurses—and not just the young ones just coming out of school, but just as often the middle and older generations—struggle to be effectively present because they’re on their phones all the time.

I see informal bans, and well motivated individuals, but I haven’t seen it “become the norm thing” for workplaces to do as the schools are starting to do yet. Curious if it will.

➕ show 4 replies
maaaaattttt • today at 2:14 PM

In France in 1956 they were passing a law that forbid children below 14yo to get alcohol served at the school cantine (https://youtu.be/n_Ez2RMjwuA - TV report from that time in French). I hope we will get laws forbidding phones in schools, or to children in general, and my guess is that it will resonate like this one for future generations.

➕ show 2 replies
willphill • today at 12:43 PM

It should have been done years ago. My partner is a teacher and she was so frustrated by pupils having phones (more recently, secretly) in the classroom. I don't know why it was ever allowed.

➕ show 5 replies
rdudek • today at 1:43 PM

Are the test scores improving because of the phone bans or are they improving because we're getting past the COVID era school lockdowns and things are going back to normal?

➕ show 4 replies
tfirst • today at 2:31 PM

The identification in this study is a sketchy, and a similar study in the exact same setting ((https://tom-dee.github.io/files/w35132.pdf) doesn't find a significant effect.

1. they see diverging pre-trends, which immediately suggests a problem in the diff-in-diff 2. they're doing some kind of propensity score matching to build a comparison set, and it looks like they're matching across state lines, which is going to expose them to all sorts of weird state-level shocks 3. while the previous study just looked at the impacts on grades, they've built a value-added model and they're estimating their effects through that. That just adds another place where they can get the model wrong and end up with bad estimates.

They also point out that the schools that bought these pouches had more ESSER money, which they could have spent on tutoring.

satyambnsal • today at 6:26 PM

yeah that;s good. now I can think about having kids lol. my nephew doesn't even eat anything without staring at screen and I'm very concerned, her mother though is not much. how hard it is to understand that these screens are chewing our attention capacity. we are scrolling endlessly. there should be a separate subject on responsible use of technology in India.

cpburns2009 • today at 2:39 PM

What I want to know is when was the original ban removed? When I was in high school in the mid-late aughts, cell phones in lockers were tolerated, but if a teacher ever caught you with one in class it would be confiscated until the end of the day.

dan_grec • today at 12:49 PM

I live in a small mountain town in BC and I really hope the who town bans smart phones for kids by the time our 3 year old goes to school.

I think it’s much easier for everyone if nobody has one - nobody is missing out, parents are not the bad guys, etc.

They’re screwing up the lives of so many adults, I feels it’s a certainty we’ll look back in some years and wonder wtf we were thinking giving them to kids.

➕ show 1 reply
whh • today at 5:42 PM

I found myself researching dumb phones on the weekend. I kind of miss my Blackberry. BBM, email and a phone. iPod in the other pocket.

Those were the days.

Eddy_Viscosity2 • today at 12:32 PM

Amazing to me they were ever allowed in the first place.

➕ show 6 replies
lrvick • today at 6:03 PM

I do not have a cell phone plan or carry a phone but when I need to be reachable I carry a pager. These work for kids too!

fn-mote • today at 12:43 PM

School-issued laptops constantly available. A phone is doing something, but there are a lot of negative factors at play.

➕ show 4 replies
cafp12 • today at 1:47 PM

I wonder if it would make sense to make smartphones age restricted broadly like alcohol cigarettes or gambling.

I know that I as an adult struggle to have a good relationship with my phone. Imagine not having a fully developed brain yet.

➕ show 3 replies
ErenayDev • today at 2:50 PM

I'm currently in my final year of high school in Türkiye. Phones are strictly forbidden in all schools. However, my school allows students to use tablets for studying during class. This is useful, for example, for discussing a question with friends or showing a problem directly to the teacher. It also saves paper and reduces the weight of our bags. Despite this, I believe it is better to reduce screen time. When our eyes are less exposed to the high level of visual stimulation from screens, we can better focus on the static nature of a classroom lesson, which might otherwise feel tedious. Since I personally have no experience using tablets at school, I cant say whether they lead to any improvement in test scores

mmmlinux • today at 5:02 PM

I graduated high school in 2008. If a teacher saw your phone, they would take it and your parent would have to come get it. Oh, and you would also have detention. What happened to that.

tombert • today at 2:58 PM

I have debated moving to a dumbphone to try and cut down my YouTube addiction. Thus far the only blocker for me has been the lack of Signal support.

I am pretty convinced that having a nonstop stream of media being beamed into us is a bad thing. I kind of miss being "bored". Like, truly bored, like being stuck on the train without any means to entertain myself outside of what's in my head (and maybe reading the safety notifications).

➕ show 2 replies
hollowonepl • today at 4:51 PM

No brainer.

Parents who hive their kids phones and tablets to own and to use without control are killing their kids’ childhoods.

Those devices all but smart!

broof • today at 4:13 PM

this doesn't surprise me at all. what surprises me is somehow people think this is unique to kids in school. Why not adults at home or in the office? I'm not saying we should ban phones for adults obviously, just pointing out that their strong negative effects on learning and social activity and others are definitely not limited to kids.

jeanpah • today at 2:35 PM

Maybe it's me, but since I deleted most of my social media I feel better and can articulate longer ideas. But the feeling of boredom is crushing. I can't find something to do with the time I wasted in social media before, any ideas?

➕ show 1 reply
hefner1456 • today at 2:04 PM

i hope chromebooks and Blooket are next. I was shocked when I found out Blooket was part of his leaning. All the kids do is mash the buttons so they can get in game currency or whatever that crap is. The questions werent even tailored to his age group

piker • today at 1:53 PM

As a parent, it's clear: time to start cutting technology from children--social media, cell phones, tablets, AI, even internet--until we've returned to at least Millennial academic achievement levels.

marknutter • today at 6:06 PM

Does anyone know why schools ever allowed this in the first place? I've heard anecdotally that it was due to parents putting pressure on them to allow their kids to have phones in school, but I'd like to know what the root cause has been over the years.

➕ show 1 reply
nekusar • today at 3:53 PM

The problem isnt the phones. Never was.

The problem is extreme psychological "games" played on every app with hordes of behaviorists turning the Skinner Box to 1000000.

Its easy to go after under 18 cause they cant vote you out, or really do much of anything. Schools are fiefdoms run by the principal and superintendent. But we see this extreme addictiveness and gamification across all humans.

huubhermsen • today at 1:45 PM

Here in the Netherlands we see an increase in total bans in schools as well. Most schools already banned phones in the classroom. Although I do support it I do have to remind myself that I loved wearing my walkman between classes back in the day or playing on my gameboy during recess. I think as a parent I'm in the end responsible for my kids usage of mobile devices.

cryptoegorophy • today at 4:31 PM

Isn’t it common sense or what am I missing?

Bill2Lewis • today at 2:25 PM

No - that's not what the evidence shows; it's just what the NY Times reported! The results from several studies yields a more nuanced report.

jimnotgym • today at 2:36 PM

If they allowed phones into the test, those test scores would improve even more.

I'm hoping that the study authors framed the question more rigorously than the headline writers.

mmooss • today at 5:59 PM

Are you still using your phone all day? You think it's just the kids?

hypfer • today at 12:52 PM

I remember using early smartphones to hang out in IRC, Jabber etc with people that vibed a lot better than what was available on-site.

Kids won't have that escape hatch anymore once you blanket ban these devices.

But I suppose it makes sense. The majority absolutely got their brain fried by the products SV (read: HN) built and we need to protect the majority.

I wonder what the next generation of misfit kids will come up with. Or maybe we will create school environments that work for all kinds of people? Nah. Of course not.

➕ show 4 replies
groundzeros2015 • today at 4:09 PM

Impossible to establish causality here.

aczerepinski • today at 3:59 PM

This is a good start. Now do Chromebooks.

livinglist • today at 5:43 PM

Growing up in China we were not allowed to have phones in classrooms, although we still came up with ways to bring and use it at risk of being confiscated by our teachers. Bringing an extra fake model phone was one of the ways. Fun times.

TacticalCoder • today at 12:51 PM

Definitely banned at my kid's school: not only the phones go into a locked locker at the beginning of the day but in addition to that if the phone even rings (phonecall, alarm, anything), it's a warning. First warning: phone is confiscated and moved outside the locker and the kid has to go pick it at the end of day and explain what happened. Second warning: parents have to come get it. Third warning: kids cannot, ever, take a phone to school.

My daughter got a first warning and a few days later I received a letter citing a law article (about how phones cannot be used during school hours).

It's great IMO.

➕ show 2 replies
miika • today at 1:52 PM

If work places would ban phones from toilets, I wonder why much that would improve productivity :) I bet people spend way more time in toilets now comparing to 20 years ago.

atleastoptimal • today at 2:46 PM

Least surprising result ever

andai • today at 3:21 PM

I remember my reaction to seeing an iPhone in school. It must have been 2010.

"Oh. This thing is designed to make you retarded."

api • today at 4:39 PM

Banning hyper-addictive distraction machines improves test scores. Imagine that.

miiiiiike • today at 2:36 PM

Who let kids have phones at school?

artursapek • today at 1:45 PM

Highly recommend Waldorf school for K-8.

rumburak • today at 3:21 PM

>let's fuck freedom to make the line go up

malkia • today at 4:46 PM

... or AI/LLMs?

blocked_againnn • today at 4:43 PM

Really? I thought it was because Trump got elected. How did you prove it was phone ban instead.

maxwellito • today at 2:00 PM

Can we have the same thing at workplaces ?

Mistletoe • today at 1:50 PM

Imagine what it could do for the adults…

This effect is not confined to those in schools.

➕ show 1 reply
learntoplaypitc • today at 3:32 PM

[flagged]

🔗 View 7 more comments