logoalt Hacker News

uptrails • today at 2:11 AM • 19 replies • view on HN

> When you typed who is on snl tonight? You used to get 10 pages of clickbait that made you scroll down endlessly for the answer.

Right. Why? That's a nightmare that Google built for us. They lined the pockets of SEO spammers, and because it was their business, they talked the talk but were never willing to truly deal with the problem.

But even in your SNL example, to show you the answer, Google AI needs to take it from someone who actually made an effort to put this information online. Network programming is an rare corner case where the person doesn't mind the bot slurping it up because the goal is to get people to watch SNL, not to visit a website. But there is so much non-commercial content on the internet that is really getting hosed right now, and that people probably simply won't be putting online anymore because they don't want to do free labor for OpenAI or Google.

As a practical example, there's a lot of hobby historian communities dedicated to specific places, periods, or types of collectibles, and the only reason they exist is to bring people together and share their finds and wisdom. If you're a historian of Kinder Surprise toys or old military uniforms or whatever, and Google is now taking your work without letting you connect with like-minded individuals, there's really little incentive left.


Replies

nvarsj • today at 11:55 AM

It's very true. I am hesitant to post things I think are novel now because I know it will just go into training data, unattributed. I even comment on HN a lot less. It's wholesale ripping off of people's IP - the chilling effects of this will not be felt for a while.

➕ show 8 replies
cortesoft • today at 4:41 AM

> If you're a historian of Kinder Surprise toys or old military uniforms or whatever, and Google is now taking your work without letting you connect with like-minded individuals, there's really little incentive left.

Won't the people who are interested in connecting with like minded individuals click through anyway? The 40% who aren't clicking now are the people who were just coming to get the info and bounce, they weren't the ones connecting with like minded individuals.

➕ show 3 replies
QuantumGood • today at 6:28 PM

Those with disagreeable intent optimized to show up higher in search results. Google still shows sources, so those with "bring people together" intent can be found by those looking for that ("without letting you connect"). Connection strategists have long connected to social media forums, and pre-AI, had to deal with Google prioritizing useful info visible in the snippet shown in results; your answer could be seen without clicking.

_delirium • today at 6:48 AM

I think there is probably some long-tail data, but I'm skeptical a large volume of questions actually ended up going to hobbyist historian communities in the first place. Unless I'm misremembering the before times, like 99% of my history-related queries on Google led me to Wikipedia. I might as well have been doing a site:wikipedia.org search for how reliably that happened. Now, the AI Overview just summarizes the same Wikipedia article. Not a huge change in that particular niche imo, unless you're tracking Wikipedia pageviews. Which even as a longtime Wikipedia editor I don't care about (I don't edit it to rack up pageviews).

➕ show 1 reply
bitmasher9 • today at 3:50 AM

Those niche special interests will always have hangout spots. YouTubers putting out weekly videos, subreddits, discord servers, facebook groups, irc channels, conventions. As long as it’s something popular enough to have a certain critical mass —- maybe one thousand dedicated fans world wide —- there’s going to be places to hang out.

Who cares if it isn’t googleable. There’s other ways to build community and other avenues to be recognized for your work.

➕ show 5 replies
kolinko • today at 4:27 PM

I think if someone is looking for a human connection through hobby/passion, the ai results are a net benefit.

The hobby pages/communities get hit to some extent, but the upside is that it is way easier to find local communities and hack projects that help you with whatever the passion is.

Two real downsides are that way more discussion moves to locked threads and offline, and that certain hobbies can get locked into what is the current training set.

E.g. with dance, Argon and Carbon give feedback almost comparable to best teachers (sic), but then this may prevent the evolution of the form if everyone begins treating it as truth.

genxy • today at 4:11 AM

Google directly and indirectly benefits from SEO spam. They are a solution to a messy web, the messier the web, the more necessary they are. Without web spam, Google would have just been another search engine next to Altavista.

Google is also in the unique position of selling both search ads and display ads. And they know what a visitors ad exposure is for links in the search results. They make money on both sides of the click.

➕ show 1 reply
0xWTF • today at 4:39 PM

Google wasn't the first one to monetize their search page. But they came to dominate search so we forget about Ask Jeeves, Lycos, AltaVista, and Excite.

➕ show 1 reply
shadowgovt • today at 12:07 PM

FWIW, having known the people responsible at Google for dealing with SEO spam...

It was never a question of resources and it was never a conflicting goals issue. From Google's standpoint, SEO spam is an existential threat because if somebody solves filtering for it, everyone will switch to that competitor.

It is simply a hard problem to solve at scale. Successful spammers live on the razor line between the signals Google has for useful content and wasting people's time.

The element Google can't control for is human nature. SEO spam sites are built to keep organic users reading long enough to tip the quality signal in the site's favor. Savvy users like those in this conversation know what they look like, but remember that most of the internet is not composed of sanity users. So the signal Google mostly gets from those pages is that they are holding user attention, and holding user attention, and holding use your attention because the site is annoying to retrieve information from is difficult to distinguish from holding user attention because the site is good.

fennecfoxy • today at 5:15 PM

>Google did it

Idk I think you're standing too close to the wall. If you step back you realise that the majority of human behaviour is consistent across Millenia and that it's more to do with our evolution learned behaviours than anything else.

Before Google newspapers did the same thing. Tabloids and other rags. Word of mouth information delivered per that individual's tribal affectations.

As a side-note I always find it so childlike, the way so many people think our species is special. You look at behaviours like person did crime -> people look at mugshot and say "yeah, they look like a creepy xyz!" (even though plenty of good people look like that person. It's the deep down guts of our learned behaviours; practicing identifying bad people or things just like watching puppies play-fighting. Sure, society bla bla but when you peel that veneer up you can see that we're all still cavemen lmao.

BeFlatXIII • today at 1:16 PM

> that people probably simply won't be putting online anymore because they don't want to do free labor for OpenAI or Google

I have bad news about their private anti-AI Discord communities.

dumbfounder • today at 11:36 AM

“Non-commercial content”. I’m not sure this is a thing anymore.

runarberg • today at 3:45 PM

For reference here is the DuckDuckGo results. Just a link to NBC‘s SNL page where I presume you can get the answer from the immediate subtitle:

> John Mulaney hosts Saturday Night Live on November 14, 2026, with musical guest Phoebe Bridgers

https://imgur.com/a/CbdynGL

Note I don‘t know anything about SNL, nor who any of these people are, and have no idea how accurate this is, but I assume that NBC’s own webpage is much more trustworthy then some AI summary from Google.

Pxtl • today at 3:08 PM

Google could use the LLM to find the best hit in the SRPs and put those before the synopsis. It would take more context but if it has an idea of what the answer is it could review the text content of the top hits and check them against what it think the user is looking for.

Of course more often than not the reference links within LLM responses don't really relate to what they're saying - LLMs act like highschoolers, "I need X references to back up my essay, so I'll find some things that sound relevant and put them in as footnotes".

neutronicus • today at 1:59 PM

It’s a push to do cheap labor for Google and make YouTube videos instead of text

vr46 • today at 2:52 PM

I still keep my own website devoted to most of the interests I have, and sure, those opinions and information are destined for aggregation, but at least they are still worth something and reaching an audience, even if they are not the way I planned.

Once you've created something, whether it's an album or a blogpost, they are like your children - or as Kahlil Gibran wrote:

  They come through you but not from you,
  And though they are with you yet they belong not to you.
When people's interest is piqued, they may investigate more deeply, and that may lead them to other people in the same way. Discord servers are doing pretty well.

Personally, I'm a follower of Bowie's definition of success, in that success is about how much you influence other people, because it's purer and happens even if they hate you.

                  CREATING SOMETHING
         __________________________________
      .-'                                  '-.
    .'                                        '.
   /                                            \
  /                                              \
 |      Curiosity                                |
 |                   Joy                         |
 |          Art                                  |
 |                      Experimentation          |
 |     Learning                                  |
 |                 Self-expression               |
 |                           Play                |
 |         Discovery                             |
 |                                               |
 |                                ___            |
 |       Making things         .-'   '-.         |
 |       just because         / MONEY   \        |
 |       you want to          \         /        |
  \                            '-.___.-'         /
   \                                            /
    '.                                      _.'
      '-.________________________________.-'

Monetisation is just one possible consequence of creation. We've somehow mistaken it for the purpose. Because capitalism.
evolighting • today at 2:45 AM

Well, I'd say if people want communities, they'll always find a way to build connections—that part hasn't changed anyway.

The real difference comes down to who's paying the bill for all the server stuff. "Clicks" bring in ad revenue, which is what kept the internet "free" all these years, but that model might be coming to an end.

Nothing really free in the beginning after all.

tyre • today at 5:43 AM

I’m sorry but there is no one needed to post who is on SNL tonight, nor when certain sporting events are occurring, nor when the next episode of $SHOW comes on.

These are far more common than niche hobby collectible communities, and if those communities love bringing people together those people can still hang out together!

People who are looking for others with a similar passion—which, if it’s a niche interest, sounds quite nice—still have access to search results or the sources shown on the AI summary.

But for the vast majority of things, we don’t need 29 sites competing for SEO on “Which channel is the US Open on?”