Does anyone else find stuff like this weirdly soulless?
I was at a puppet head making workshop recently, and the facilitator passed around a 3d print of a puppet head designed by an LLM. I found my eyes glazed over it, even though I found some of the hand-sculpted clay heads utterly fascinating.
Generally, I want to consume much less LLM output than I do. I'm confused why people care about projects like this.
Have you considered that your perspective on these physical artifacts was biased because of what you were told about them?
If the facilitator told you afterwards that actually, the 3d print was designed by a human and the hand-sculpted ones were made by a machine how would that change how you feel about this?
And if they again told you that they tricked you and both of them were made by hand, or both made by a machine?
Bc the actual thing that we are enjoying and looking for in this work is not aesthetics as we have long believed but purely the sense of the presence of the creator. This stuff made by robotic calculations means nothing because it comes from nobody, so we learn nothing about being ourselves through the work of others from it. It has proven, at long last, that aesthetics mean nothing
I agree it's soulless, and the "wrote the wolf in grandma's gown a thousand years ago, run your Audit" is classic Claudish.
Given that the video is actually a commentary about LLMs and AI, I can look past all that though.
The question is do you find it soulless if you don’t know it was produced in a pasteurized prose factory?
Yes.
I can't even make myself read a single sentence. I see it, I know what it is, and my brain couldn't be less interested. I hit space a few times to scroll the page and then I'm out.
It somehow reminds me of playing MIDI music in the 90s.