logoalt Hacker News

smartmic • today at 1:00 PM • 9 replies • view on HN

Good intentions, but I would like to see a balanced discussion involving also the risks of geoengineering. It is always delicate if we interfere with a system we have not yet fully understood.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geoengineering


Replies

andrewvc • today at 1:31 PM

I wish we could afford to be very circumspect about geo engineering. There’s been too much warming to be slow about it.

If reduction alone was an effective strategy we wouldn’t be where we are today.

➕ show 7 replies
scarecrowbob • today at 5:34 PM

Much of the current discussion around geoengineering feels, to me, quite reminiscent of eugenics discussions I've read from 100 or so years ago.

vjvjvjvjghv • today at 2:51 PM

Yeah, it seems pretty crazy to attempt geoengineering while we can't even agree on how the current climate works.

➕ show 2 replies
tito • today at 1:07 PM

Here here! Would love to hear about what format you would like to see this in. There’s some existing discussion I can point you to but there’s so much more to be discussed about what we do understand, and so much to be explored that we don’t understand. At the same time, warming is accelerating and inaction is having real consequences too.

➕ show 1 reply
JoeAltmaier • today at 7:34 PM

Normal and accepted to hurtle on heedless with industrial emissions - geoengineering with no thought to the consequences.

Somebody wants to try remediation, and instantly folks say Whoa! Not so fast!

Towaway69 • today at 4:15 PM

With so many great geoengineering ideas on “saving” the planet, i wonder how the earth got so far without us and our good intentions.

The earth seems to get along just fine without us and it keeps showing us by somehow always being the last thing standing when yet another civilisation collapses - as ours will too.

chris_va • today at 3:48 PM

I'm sorry ma'am, we cannot give your son cancer treatment because we do not fully understand how the body works.

(disclaimer that I manage a climate research group, and this hit a nerve because we've had balanced discussions on this topic ad nauseam for the last 30+ years)

bell-cot • today at 4:05 PM

Maybe "yes" in the abstract - but was there any Geoengineering discussion about removing the sulfur, thereby altering the centuryish-long status quo?

And as soon as a major country experiences a climate event (especially heat wave) which seriously endangers its ruling class, the gloves are going to come off - "Shut up and seed those big, reflective clouds NOW."

throwaway2037 • today at 1:12 PM

China has already be doing it for more than 20 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beijing_Weather_Modification_O...

➕ show 1 reply