I wish we could afford to be very circumspect about geo engineering. There’s been too much warming to be slow about it.
If reduction alone was an effective strategy we wouldn’t be where we are today.
There's been a few interesting proposals for solar shade to block like 1.5% or so of the sun's light at the lagrange point. One using a single shield as opposed to a swarm (seems more reliable) would require like 100-200 starships to lift the mass. Probably relatively cheap in terms of geoengineering if starship actually becomes a standard lift vehicle at their targeted costs. Doesn't fix acidification, but is a lot more reversible than many geoengineering plans.
> There’s been too much warming to be slow about it.
And yet we're still pumping up fossil fuels and this geoengineering would be used as an excuse to keep doing it. At some point we're going to feel other effects or potentially be trapped expending resources to keep the geoengineering going.
Anything we do is geoengineering. So in terms of outcome, choosing the outcome seems like the superior option to just letting things happen.
What you're worried about is people looking for someone to blame ... and finding you. Politics, in other words.
Although I'll agree with politics on one front: any form of geoengineering, including further increasing global warming, will have winners and losers. And global warming is pretty unique in that it essentially only has winners. The earth becomes greener, more fertile, and needs a lot less heat. Fixing it will ... well, it will do the opposite.
> There’s been too much warming to be slow about it.
Exactly! We must learn to cope with it. Without stopping to look for a solution that does not impact the economy negatively.
> If reduction alone was an effective strategy we wouldn’t be where we are today.
Any strategy which you fail to apply is going to be ineffective.
The main problem with geoengineering is not the unintended consequences, the unknown unknowns, etc. It's that it would require massive, coordinated effort.
The reason I say that's the main problem, is because that's also the main problem with reducing fossil fuel usage.
It's fun to debate the technical details of geoengineering (solar shades, atmospheric aerosols, enhanced weathering, etc.), in the same way that it's fun to debate the technical details of carbon reduction (energy storage methods, approaches to electrical transmission, remote work, land use, etc.).
But none of that really matters if we, collectively, don't actually do anything! It's not as fun as comparing scifi fantasies, but the problem we need to solve is that of getting humanity to actually do something, at scale, which is collectively acknowledged as necessary yet is not immediately/individually profitable.
If we could solve that, then we could do geoengineering; but in such a world, we might not need to, because we could also do carbon reduction, plus a bunch of other stuff!
However, if we can't solve that, then geoengineering is an illusion.
It's a grass-is-greener fallacy: what makes any geoengineering project seem remotely feasible, in a world where we can't even coordinate on the obviously-a-good-idea stuff?