logoalt Hacker News

titzer • today at 2:34 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Math has a factoring problem in that it's a very common tendency to want to minimize a formula, theorem, proof, etc by extracting out potential common parts / definitions as well as introduce notation to make it short. Like outlining a program with method names that are unicode symbols. That makes math full of indirection and cryptic symbols. Too much indirection overflows human intuition and makes things hard to understand.

It's not just math that does this, but it seems to be extreme in math.


Replies

godelski • today at 5:06 PM

I think you misunderstand math, but in a common way. Math is a language. More precisely, it is a formal language. We invented these formal languages because they are well suited for things that need no ambiguity and high precision.

  > Like outlining a program with method names that are unicode symbols.
Code is math. But the reason math says solve for "x" instead of solve for "betterVariableNameHere" is because it is traditionally done with pen and papaer and far predates the electronic computer. You could look at early computer programs, where they were constrained by space and you'll see that they too use minimalism. The reason we use long and meaningful names now is because we have tools like autocomplete.

  > That makes math full of indirection and cryptic symbols.
But this is true of any language. "It's all Chinese to me." It takes a lot of time and effort to understand any language. It's also hard to understand purely from a book and needs to be understood through its culture and the people who speak/write it. Same is true for math. Same is true for programming languages.
➕ show 1 reply
JustFinishedBSG • today at 3:11 PM

> by extracting out potential common parts / definitions as well as introduce notation to make it short.

We don't really do that to make things short, we do that to make things more understandable. People underestimate how important good notation is to properly understanding things, and mathematicians spend an inordinate amount of time just refining notation until it makes things easier to follow.

➕ show 1 reply