logoalt Hacker News

Ericson2314 • today at 5:21 PM • 6 replies • view on HN

I know we're not gonna get a perpetual motion machine from this or whatever, but I would still like someone to build a physical demonstration.

A real world approximation, where the fluid started to be "weird", for some definition of "weird", would be the ultimate Exploratorium exhibit.


Replies

HarHarVeryFunny • today at 5:59 PM

This result doesn't prove that reality can "blow up" - that you can get a water vortex moving at infinite speed - but rather that Navier Stokes incorrectly predicts that such impossibilities can happen.

I wonder if we have enough compute, and/or modelling accuracy, to do a molecule level fluid simulation to see what would REALLY happen as this blow-up scenario is approached? It's not necessarily going to be weird.

➕ show 1 reply
_notreallyme_ • today at 5:29 PM

The point was precisely to show that the set of equations, while correctly modeling fluid physics for some known solutions, could also describe impossible behaviors.

If you are familiar with the Maxwell equations, they perfectly describe all of the electromagnetic field of physics. Navier-Stokes do not have that property for the fluids, unfortunately.

➕ show 1 reply
evanb • today at 5:53 PM

Navier Stokes is a low-energy / long-wavelength approximation (an effective field theory) of the true physical description. Like all EFTs it breaks down at small length scales where it ceases to be a valid description. For example, NS doesn't account for atoms, so it HAS to be invalid as a description of real fluids if you look in enough detail.

➕ show 2 replies
uh_uh • today at 5:24 PM

As far as I understand you can't do that exactly because Navier-Stokes is not an accurate representation of how real fluids work, which is why it blows up.

Florin_Andrei • today at 6:10 PM

Navier-Stokes assumes the cow is spherical. Don't read too much into the singularities of these equations.