logoalt Hacker News

marky1991 • today at 5:27 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

If your problem is polluting, shouldn't you ban polluting then?

The cruise thing is an irrelevant detail.

"Let's not pretend like banning cruise ships will lead to banning "all things not strictly required for life" like going for a walk."

If that's not what you're saying then you need to explain how the analysis is wrong and what's so special about crusises morally.


Replies

apf6 • today at 5:44 PM

Your logic is overly reductionist, slippery-slope, and lacking context. We already ban recreational things like the use of lead bullets for hunting, or the use of fireworks in areas with fire danger, or using snowmobiles in some protected national parks. The decision to ban something recreational involves weighing a bunch of factors including the impact of the thing, and whether there are equivalent less-impactful alternatives. So no, the fact that it's a cruise is not an irrelevant detail, it gets considered along with other factors.

trashb • today at 5:45 PM

  > If your problem is polluting, shouldn't you ban polluting then?
Wouldn't that be great, I think the governments around the world seem to be moving in that direction (where feasible). Let's start with the biggest polluters that have the least societal value. I think you will reach cruise ships quite quickly in that list.

Why don't you explain what's so special about cruises morally that we should keep them even though they are huge polluters and riddled with other problems?

Because even though there is a clear alternative (go to a hotel). Why Do you need to be on a hotel on the sea with 6500 other passengers so bad that it warrants destroying the planet?