logoalt Hacker News

dead_hn_theory • today at 9:06 PM • 13 replies • view on HN

I'm going to try to stay on topic: what are the practical use-cases for the folks here who are running Windows Server, to continue to do so? Momentum? Legal?


Replies

e40 • today at 9:14 PM

Cooperative development on Windows. That's how we've used it. We're on 2012 R2 still. We run a very, very narrow set of tools and don't uses browsers on the machine.

We updated a 2nd machine to 2016, but with SSDs the performance was as bad as the 2012 R2 machine with spinners. OLD spinners.

I spent 2 days looking into how to purchase a more modern version... honestly, I was shocked how confusing it was. That was a couple of years ago.

wvenable • today at 9:21 PM

The reason why anyone runs any OS: because it runs the software that we need.

Some of that software might be dependency of some other software which is a dependency on some other software deployed everywhere.

Almost any organization is a complex series of integrations -- almost nothing is it's own silo that doesn't communicate with another system or application.

NikolaNovak • today at 9:18 PM

In big enterprises it's fairly pervasive for all the imaginable reasons - the ubiquity of Office / Exchange to run your business, and the build out through Active Directory and outwards to properly capture your IT.

FYI / fwiw and on a more specific note, we use them as RDP to run a large number of software and utilities only available in Windows form. For example, the Peoplesoft ERP can and does run on Linux and aix, but the proprietary GUI IDE is windows only. Our dbas use Toad. For whatever reason our RPA Blueprism is running on windows as well.

aetherspawn • today at 9:25 PM

Honestly because it’s cheaper than Enterprise Linux: buy CD keys of Windows Server perpetual licenses for like $100 rather than $900/year subscription per CPU for something like RHEL.

I find Windows to be more stable, too. RHEL kept randomly dropping fiber optic adapters every few weeks, which would require network manager to be restarted, and nobody knew why. Stock standard Dell PowerEdge with certified RHEL, supposed to be rock solid but not as stable as expected

➕ show 1 reply
wmchen • today at 9:12 PM

Typically Active Directory, and organizational inertia (existing software is meant to run on Windows Server, knowledge/contractors/etc. are familiar with WinServer) as you mentioned. Sometimes, certain applications are only certified for compliance on Windows Server. Small businesses seem to run Windows Server because it comes with a UI, usually because IT is an off-the-side of the desk thing for someone.

thisisnico • today at 9:22 PM

Local AD, Fileserver, Integration between services, DNS and DHCP, MS SQL Server for ERP Systems.

mamcx • today at 9:21 PM

The main? This is like ask: Why use a linux server(should be a windows one!) when I use a linux desktop?

That way, in server I user power shell and in desktop bash! how should be!

jojogeo • today at 9:11 PM

Usually org enforced in my experience, or folks running onprem AD:DS etc.

ortusdux • today at 9:10 PM

I know of one case where the answer is CMMC compliance for a few odd reasons.

SV_BubbleTime • today at 9:10 PM

A. We need to run Windows programs. Our 3D cad PDM is windows only. Our ERP is windows only. Our camera system and access controls, also windows. We need to work with other businesses, and guess what? They use windows too. It’s pure fantasy that you can run many businesses without Windows. Maybe self-contained ones that sell software or services directly to customers. I’m in automotive; it’s all windows.

B. Our MSP like almost all of them is a windows shop. It’s what they know how to use and they can train employees on it. We could hire internal IT, but it would be at least double what we’re paying our pretty good MSP and we don’t need to deal with staffing. We aren’t an IT company and don’t want to be.

Personally, I won’t use windows ever again. But, most of our people have no choice. Put it down to institutional momentum if you must.

lenerdenator • today at 9:12 PM

C-suite and execs know it, the software the customer is running on it is proven stable for their use case (inertia as opposed to momentum), and maybe the people deciding on things get intimidated by figuring out which other OS to use. Do you use Red Hat? Canonical? Do you give a child's eternal soul over to Larry Ellison as a part of the contract for Oracle Linux? If you just stick with Windows Server, for better or worse, you don't have to answer these questions.