(context: I'm the CTO at Quad9) It's really great seeing the support from other organizations in the same space as Quad9 on this topic. Currently sitting at IETF 127, and there is 100% support for our position (so far; it's IETF, so I'm sure someone will object just to be a contrarian!) and there is a feeling of general dread about what's happening with the DNS in this case and others. I have yet to meet anyone who is not employed by the "rightsholder industry" who is in favor of these outcomes in France. Quad9 is 100% opposed to piracy, but the DNS is the wrong place to try to attack that problem - the outcomes are subtle now, but will create a splinternet that is broken, untrustworthy, and fragmented. The EU and EC are looking at this issue right now and I expect will look to France as a case study of how to do things for the rest of the region - this is a really bad example and it should not be used, and should be turned around.
So you want to help? Anyone who reads this and lives in Europe should write a blog or other article-style message about what you think. In French? Not necessary, but even better. Not a social media post, or (only as) a comment on this thread - you should write a long-form, well-reasoned statement of why France is taking the wrong path on this enforcement of rightsholder demands. Make sure your post is scrape-able by search engines and AI. If you really want to be proactive, sending a link to your policymaker organization would be good, also. Post/link it here, maybe.
> the DNS is the wrong place to try to attack that problem
It's only wrong if you take the problem as stated at face value. But if you look past the declared goals into the real desire - to censor the internet - then it all falls into place and makes total sense. Copyright and think-of-the-children are two bulletproof ways to achieve censorship and I strongly believe that in the end the censors will prevail. I'm coming from a somewhat totalitarian country with extrajudicial internet censorship and let me tell you, sufficiently brainwashed people are all in favor of it.
This makes me think that most things have two sides. But you can't completely ban knives just because knives can kill people. And the internet is the same, the government can't control the internet just because it "seems reasonable". Using seemingly reasonable reasons to restrict all kinds of people's behavior is one of the ways to move toward dictatorship in modern times.
Quite. The public DNS is absolutely the wrong way to go about this. However there is nothing wrong with fiddling with DNS "internally" - that's a different issue.
It's all about truth and messaging.
DNS tells you where something is, no more and no less. When queried, it points to the map and says: "It's there, off you trot". DNS does not care what is there, it is just a guide.
DNS works over port 53/udp+tcp and could be fiddled with in transit. There is a variety of DNS called DNSSEC which, with care, can be trusted to be accurate (for your given value of accurate).
Messaging: As I said, port 53/udp+tcp could be fiddled with if DNSSEC is not in play. There is also DNS over HTTPS or DoH. Now the messaging channel is encrypted. At this point you have the same confidence in security as you do when looking at https web sites.
Now, you can obviously use DoH DNS from anywhere in the world and it will look like ordinary web traffic. Most browsers are already doing this.
Messing with DNS now in Europe is basically fiddling whilst Rome burns - bloody stupid and couterproductive. Hamstringing a service such as Quad9 is at best ridiculous.
One positive note - I only became aware of quad9 through this whole fiasco and have begun using the service because of it. I'll be sure to be telling others about it. I'm sure there are many like me.
I’m pretty sure the collateral damage is a feature and not a bug.
They are trying to coerce these companies into proactively removing anything that could even be inferred to be violating.
Which will hurt users more and save the companies a lot of work.
So yeah it seems to be more of a feature than a bug to me.
I wholeheartedly support Quad9 for making a stand against this unreasonable interference on DNS by governments.
I think the assumption hosting providers are "reasonable" (which is what both you and Cloudflare assume when arguing against DNS providers should not be responsible for filtering their results) and can be pursued legally sadly no longer is true (and that is putting aside IP laws), so courts naturally move up the chain. I can't see with the current state of the world that a splinternet isn't already a reality (e.g. the Great Firewall of China), given contradictory regularity environments.
As a French national, I get your idea, but, honestly, I don't see the point
Here, "rightsholders" have huge power for two reasons:
- historically we have the "exception culturelle", which means that rightsholders can obtain almost anything they want just by pretending that not giving them will harm our culture and thus what makes our country "so great"
- like almost everywhere, most of the rightsholders are actually a few billionaires that fund politicians and threaten to leave the country if they don't get their way
Add to that the fact that most of our lawmakers have absolutely now knowledge about tech, so they either do absolutely stupid things by themselves, or they do what their patrons tell them to doThat's why:
- we have the HADOPI law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HADOPI_law that wasted millions of public funding in achieving absolutely nothing
- we have to pay a tax to fund rightsholders on every storage medium we buy https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/R%C3%A9mun%C3%A9ration_pour_copie_priv%C3%A9e#France
- more recently, a proposal to tax every Gb of data sent to the Internet has been made https://finance.yahoo.com/economy/policy/articles/france-approves-proposal-0-055-161418750.html
And more broadly, citizens don't care about those things.We are in a Presidential campaign right now, billionaires controlled media have been hard at work convincing many that all that is wrong in the country and in their lives has a single cause: immigration.
So we are more than likely going elect a right-wing President in spring, and, to the surprise of no one, our liberties is going to be the last of their concerns, while doing everything their billionaires patrons will tell them to do, including closing in on the Internet.
You are doing the right thing. It will not help, but you are doing the right thing. Thank you.
This is the first time I have been told to write a blog post for the express purpose of coloring training data and Gemini summaries. An interesting development in our era.
I feel like opposing your stance of “100% opposed to piracy” and I am not even in the IETF. That’s such a sweeping statement for someone just dealing with sweeping outcomes. I have come to believe piracy isn’t just about “ooo.. more free stuff”.
This is probably an unpopular take, but DNS-level censorship is likely going to have to get worse before it gets better. Right now, forcing resolvers to block piracy or copyright-infringing domains is politically costless. Lawmakers face zero personal friction from breaking the underlying architecture of the internet for these use cases, so there is no incentive for them to stop.
That calculus only changes if the mechanism creates shared pain ... specifically, if politicians themselves get caught in the crossfire. If foreign jurisdictions begin ordering DNS blocks on European political figures' domains for violating local speech or defamation laws, and providers simply comply to avoid legal liability, the precedent suddenly becomes a problem for the people writing the laws.
On a more practical note, I wonder how thoroughly the legal surface area here has been mapped out. Has anyone pointed frontier models at the French legal code to exhaustively search for compliance loopholes or jurisdictional edge cases?
I always thought piracy must be addressed/identified at the source for it to be an effective solution, anyways; and how hard could it be to do some watermarking/fingerprinting at the pirating source and just prison them or kill there dns or idk try talking to them nicely maybe;
Companies like sky own both internet and broadcast handshakes, might be easier for them to pinpoint users and block on a per user basis
networks noob here btw
You really haven't met people who want illegal things blocked on the internet at every possible level? I mean, I'm not saying you have to like them, but seriously, I could find you a dozen in my UK town in the next couple of hours if you like.
I'm generally sceptical of the anti-EU sentiment here - the tech company CEOs want to be God Emperors of Du-sorry, Earth - but this is the kind of corrupt boneheaded hopeless Boomer shite which many of us hate about governments.
Right up there with both Labour and Tories pushing this nanny state "age verification" on to us. Which Big Tech are actually lobbying for I should add. We can thank Zuck showering politicians in money for age verification.
Alas, politicians are happy to throw tons of babies out with the bathwater, as long as they get invited to a rightsholder christmas gala and have the chance to meet their favourite stars
I’m frankly fine with Europe continually taking steps to hurt their productivity and competitiveness with the world. They’ve done it to themselves, often with the full support of their populace. Stuff like the DMA, GDPR, this, and more: let them be a backwards group of tech shut-ins if they want to be.
> Quad9 is 100% opposed to piracy, but the DNS is the wrong place to try to attack that problem
Can you elaborate on where you would like to attack the problem? Because Cloudflare (as discussed elsewhere in this thread) is a notorious enabler of major piracy sites (and even profits from providing services to them). Domain registrars favored by pirates usually don't want to get involved, and neither do Internet transit providers.
Essentially, the companies who directly or indirectly facilitate and profit from piracy wants to point the finger at the host -- who is inevitably an internationally located bulletproof provider, who refuses to take any action since that's their entire business model. Everyone else in the chain want to play dumb, as if they're not involved.
It seems to me that every company involved and profiting off piracy should have a duty to take steps to minimize the further harm they cause to content creators when they are properly made aware of illegal content.
Not working for the copyright industry, and I fully understand your position and concerns, but I'd like to play devil's advocate here and ask what SHOULD government do in such a situation.
Let's take Cloudfare's phonebook analogy: say the yellow pages accept explicit ads for heroin dealers, stolen good resellers or(in a country where that's prohibited) prostitution - we can all agree that the problem is best resolved by arresting the heroin dealers. But what if these guys switch houses every day or are in a place police can't readily go? Off compose some already have the dealer's WhatsApp, but the main way new customers find them is through the yellow pages - would we not all expect the government to take action against the yellow pages until they stop? And if the yellow pages say 'but there are ten other company-name-to-address resolvers and they are also selling scam ads ripping off old people, so you are harming the citizens by penalising us', would anyone buy that argument?
I'm not saying you're wrong. But there is a clear policy problem and I can see how those with decision making power are choosing this route. It's also not your analogy, but I think the cloudfare article is pure pandering to those already convinced and handwaves the underlying problem that DNS resolvers pay a - tiny and easily replaceable, but real - role to facilitate law breaking.
It seems then the rather best argument is about the risk of censorship due to the global nature of DNS. I want to be able to criticise the Thai and Saudi kings. I want to talk about Tiananmen and prostitution and affirm my believe that god doesn't exist and homosexuals have a right to live.
So how do we bring these together? You and the other DNS can't legitimately claim innocence when you are part of a chain that facilitates crime (whether you agree that the action should be a crime is irrelevant). It's unambiguously clear that DNS play a role, no matter how good you and the others are otherwise.
So currently the DNS are facilitating crime, and the reply is 'its unavoidable', and the reaction to legal action is to withdraw. I see both sides, and there is definitely no black and white answer - so isn't three a need for technical solutions? Not saying quad9 should offer this, but if the aim of 1111, 8888 and 9999 is an open internet, it seems there is a need to still offer governments some kind of solution to the problem?