Not working for the copyright industry, and I fully understand your position and concerns, but I'd like to play devil's advocate here and ask what SHOULD government do in such a situation.
Let's take Cloudfare's phonebook analogy: say the yellow pages accept explicit ads for heroin dealers, stolen good resellers or(in a country where that's prohibited) prostitution - we can all agree that the problem is best resolved by arresting the heroin dealers. But what if these guys switch houses every day or are in a place police can't readily go? Off compose some already have the dealer's WhatsApp, but the main way new customers find them is through the yellow pages - would we not all expect the government to take action against the yellow pages until they stop? And if the yellow pages say 'but there are ten other company-name-to-address resolvers and they are also selling scam ads ripping off old people, so you are harming the citizens by penalising us', would anyone buy that argument?
I'm not saying you're wrong. But there is a clear policy problem and I can see how those with decision making power are choosing this route. It's also not your analogy, but I think the cloudfare article is pure pandering to those already convinced and handwaves the underlying problem that DNS resolvers pay a - tiny and easily replaceable, but real - role to facilitate law breaking.
It seems then the rather best argument is about the risk of censorship due to the global nature of DNS. I want to be able to criticise the Thai and Saudi kings. I want to talk about Tiananmen and prostitution and affirm my believe that god doesn't exist and homosexuals have a right to live.
So how do we bring these together? You and the other DNS can't legitimately claim innocence when you are part of a chain that facilitates crime (whether you agree that the action should be a crime is irrelevant). It's unambiguously clear that DNS play a role, no matter how good you and the others are otherwise.
So currently the DNS are facilitating crime, and the reply is 'its unavoidable', and the reaction to legal action is to withdraw. I see both sides, and there is definitely no black and white answer - so isn't three a need for technical solutions? Not saying quad9 should offer this, but if the aim of 1111, 8888 and 9999 is an open internet, it seems there is a need to still offer governments some kind of solution to the problem?
> when you are part of a chain that facilitates crime
Claiming that DNS providers contribute towards cybercrime is like saying knife manufacturers contribute towards stabbings. Let's not blame the tools when when the fault lies entirely in the hands of those abusing said tools.
> You and the other DNS can't legitimately claim innocence when you are part of a chain that facilitates crime
That's not how innocence works. You're arguing that because they could do something, they should do something. I'm not a fan of spreading enforcement all over the place, and I wouldn't want DNS enforcing this any more than I want Home Depot on the hook if murderer uses a hammer he bought there to kill someone.
> You and the other hardware stores can't legitimately claim innocence when you are part of a chain that facilitates crime
If my name is Frank Smith and I deal heroin, and in the phone book it says Frank Smith 555-1234, the phone book should take no action and the government should take no action against the phone book.
If it says Frank Smith (heroin dealer) 555-1234 the phone book is now advertising heroin and the government can make them remove that. If there's a whole section for heroin dealers the phone book themselves are now criminals for adding that section in.
The Phone book analogy only makes sense if Quad9 in that scenario is the postman that delivers the phonebook to your door. Are you planning on suing the postman for the advertisements in the phonebook?
If you follow that analogy, registrars are the Yellow Pages and they should be doing the due diligence, not the postman.
The thing is, Quad9 is already filtering out the heroin dealers, one of their major selling points is they filter out malware websites! So they can't claim they are 'just listing addresses'
So the only discussion becomes which illegal things are they filtering, and who gets to decide what things are on their filtering list.
> So currently the DNS are facilitating crime
So are gun manufacturers. But actually, so are hammer manufacturers. Why aren't we looking for a solution preventing those being used for crime? Because it's actually hard.
> isn't three a need for technical solutions?
A need, surely. Is there a pragmatic technical solutions? Well if there was, then it would be a lot smarter to enforce that than whatever France is doing, right?
My point being that the best thing to do when we don't have a good solution (France doesn't) is NOT to do something that is not considered a good solution (by definition, since we just said we don't have a good solution) and claim it's better than nothing. Many times, bad solutions are worse than nothing.
Note: the "it's better than nothing" and "at least we are doing something" is often used against immigration. A bad solution to real problems. Why do politicians go for that? Because apparently people still don't understand that "something random" is not necessarily "better than nothing". They would if they were the targets of those policies once in a while, and that's exactly why it works with immigration: because those who are targeted and may actually understand that it's not always "better than nothing" don't have the right to vote.
No, a street or cars don't facilitate getaway drivers and likewise DNS providers do not facilitate copyright infringements. I don't think the argument needs to be extended beyond that and the argument can be solved right here. If the crime is the problem, policy should focus on solving that instead. They are overwhelmed with this task obviously, hence this decision.
The argument that they are facilitating crime is wrong from the start.
> isn't three a need for technical solutions?
I don't think anyone's saying that technical solutions are by definition unnecessary. Whether or not it is, is just not relevant to the matter at hand.
Roads facilitate crime. Opposing the removal/blocking of roads is not approving of crime, and it's not on the opposer to propose a better solution to crime. The cost of blocking roads easily outweighs the benefits of reduced crime, and that is all that is needed to decide not to do it.
Not necessarily. When a proposed "solution" causes bad consequences, that does not make it the responsibility of those to whom the proposed "solution" is harmful to create an alternative solution. It is also possible to just not implement the proposed "solution".
> but the main way new customers find them is through the yellow pages
After finding them on the yellow pages, the customers call them with cellphones, so cellphone makers are also responsible?
The plain statement that DNS is facilitating crime is wild. People walk on sidewalks when they sell meth, should we rip out sidewalks?
> say the yellow pages accept explicit ads for heroin dealers
You say that like DNS advertises piracy. Please explain how the domain name system is in any way comparable to a user-searchable database for services, and not simply a postal code database linking alphanumeric codes to physical locations?
"Hey hosters, where ever this DNS record points to is banned, servers (and accounts) need to be shut down and handed over to LE."
> what SHOULD government do in such a situation
Well, they should immediately impose 10 000 000x stricter/higher penalties on all AI firms that committed far more serious copyright crimes, for starters.
Then calculate out what those penalties come to, on a daily basis, from when these companies actually committed those copyright violations (that was in January 2021 for Anthropic and 2016 for Meta, in other words they already owe 3600 times the daily penalty), and immediately impose those damages on the AI companies, to be paid out the authors of those books illegally downloaded and used for profit.
Seriously, that's step ONE. Because if this step isn't taken, can the court then just stop pretending copyright exists? Courts in France are specifically barred from applying the law selectively.
I think you are mixing your analogies.
Yellow pages example was used for the "comprehensive listing of all phone numbers" property, not for the ads.
Perhaps think of it as actual street addresses and house/building numbers assigned by local city council instead?
If a criminal activity happens at "address X" — which is a way to locate a particular property in a town, just like a domain name is translated with DNS to an actual internet IP — do you hold the maps provider (like Google or Apple Maps, or OpenStreetMap) accountable for that address still pointing to the house at that address? Should navigation stop working to this address? Should authorities be alerted when someone puts that address in into their navigation software?
City councils are "distributed" in the same way domain names and TLD registrars are, so map providers aggregate the data from all of them. Some councils are "rotten" and probably take bribes and do who-knows-what when assigning addresses and do not take care of the crime in their jurisdictions. Just like some TLDs and domain owners.
Are "navigation providers" really the place to tackle this issue?