logoalt Hacker News

bborrez • today at 2:23 AM • 12 replies • view on HN

It is impossible to sign up for ID.me if you do not use a smartphone. I know a person who is in this situation who has bonds in Treasury Direct that they now apparently cannot cash out. It's absolutely nuts that a federal agency partnered with a disreputable third party that operates in this manner.

The federal government says that all agencies need to offer logins via login.gov within two years [1]. For everyone's sake, hopefully this actually comes to fruition.

[1] https://www.nextgov.com/digital-government/2026/08/white-hou...


Replies

apitman • today at 2:45 AM

> It is impossible to sign up for ID.me if you do not use a smartphone

You can. I did it last week. I have a cell phone but use google voice as my primary phone number, which their system apparently doesn't like. I had to get on a video call as an alternative.

login.gov, on the other hand, didn't offer any alternatives so I was unable to create an account.

Overall the process was extremely irritating.

➕ show 4 replies
rootusrootus • today at 4:00 AM

Might be best to move the bonds out of Treasury Direct in that case. It is a hassle, but you can use paper forms. Here is a write-up: https://finbarrow.com/savings/treasurydirect-id-me-required-...

bayganyo • today at 5:37 AM

I don't know how effective it would be, but there is a change.org petition for adding login.gov to Treasury Direct: https://www.change.org/p/modify-the-mandatorytreasurydirect-...

➕ show 1 reply
username223 • today at 3:10 PM

Suspecting what might happen, I cashed out my treasuries before they switched to mandatory ID.me. Something about my setup broke its signup process partway through, even after I uploaded all sorts of personal information, and I would have been locked out otherwise.

chimeracoder • today at 6:14 AM

> I know a person who is in this situation who has bonds in Treasury Direct that they now apparently cannot cash out. It's absolutely nuts that a federal agency partnered with a disreputable third party that operates in this manner.

It is ridiculous that the government is forcing a third-party private vendor like this, but the Treasury Direct language is very clear that it's only your online access that is restricted - your friend can still cash out their bonds.

> If you would like to know more about ID.me or need help, you can visit ID.me’s help center (https://help.id.me/hc/en-us) or TreasuryDirect’s ID.me FAQ page (https://www.treasurydirect.gov/savings-bonds/help-center/faq...).

> If you do not sign up for ID.me, only your online access to your TreasuryDirect account will be restricted. Your account, funds, and investments remain secure. Please visit the FAQ page above, under the section, “Accessing TreasuryDirect After October 28, 2026” for more information on conducting transactions and retrieving tax documents without ID.me

Emphasis not mine.

noduerme • today at 9:12 AM

Have you actually been on the Treasury Direct website and seen how insanely bad it is? The last time I used it was a year ago, but it rivals the New Jersey state tax website as possibly the most insecure, archaic, pre-HTML4 piece of crap I've ever seen. The fact that they recently bolted on ID.me makes me feel no better about whatever they're doing with data storage; these people can't hire someone who knows how to write a POST query. They could literally give any vaguely competent coder a $250k contract and rewrite the thing from scratch and it would probably be more secure than it is.

Banditoz • today at 2:37 AM

> Agencies are required to adopt Login.gov on “in-scope public-facing websites” within two years.

I'll just wait until then. Hopefully I don't need to cash out early!

Why did they implement ID.me if login.gov is becoming a mandate?

➕ show 1 reply
thesuitonym • today at 3:04 PM

> It's absolutely nuts that a federal agency partnered with a disreputable third party

First time?

embedding-shape • today at 11:46 AM

> It's absolutely nuts that a federal agency partnered with a disreputable third party that operates in this manner

You're talking about the same government that frequently do multi-million deals with companies that the politicians in the government have ownership in? You're surprised they continue with exactly the same playbook, over and over again?

> The federal government says

Yeah, good luck with that. If anything, these last few years should tell you about how little "X says" actually means in practice, if there is no actual practical and concrete mechanism for forcing anything.

➕ show 1 reply
jart • today at 10:50 AM

Some marginalized communities don't have smartphones. I'd be scared of the tax man not including us on ID.gov but there's so little money to take because of the dismal poverty.

IFC_LLC • today at 3:24 AM

Oh come on, you’re saying this as if anyone who is working on that website understands what this means, or what id.me does. They ought to have an identity provider. They got a tender. They got an identity provider. People login. They are done.

It's not that they are doing bad things on purpose. It's actually a result of an acute mental condition called Idontcareism. Nobody cares, and nobody looks.

gwerbin • today at 2:38 AM

[flagged]