> It is impossible to sign up for ID.me if you do not use a smartphone
You can. I did it last week. I have a cell phone but use google voice as my primary phone number, which their system apparently doesn't like. I had to get on a video call as an alternative.
login.gov, on the other hand, didn't offer any alternatives so I was unable to create an account.
Overall the process was extremely irritating.
If you use Google Voice because you are an expat (not sure if you are, just wanted to let you and anybody else in this position know about this), Tello is a US carrier that is $5 a month for a texting/calls no data plan, and does wifi calling and shared data calling over your local sim in whatever country you are in. The shared data calling is a bit of a pain to get working the first time, but once I got it set up, it works so well I can even call people on my US number while driving.
Tello looks like a normal US cell number to every government and two factor system, and works as a normal US sim when you are in the US. They also do not cut off your plan if you spend too long outside the US (unlike every other carrier I am familiar with).
Google Voice is the main alternative that people use, but 10-20% of SMS two factor systems do not work with it, mostly financial and government institutions.
Is your cell phone a smartphone or a dumbphone? The person I was talking about is a retiree who uses a dumbphone that has large buttons, and nothing else. They don't have a web cam and are not tech savvy, so it seems like they are stuck. Treasury Direct and other agencies that rely only on ID.me really forgot that people like them still exist!
> login.gov, on the other hand, didn't offer any alternatives
Untrue unless something has changed recently. That one actually seems reasonable to me. You can create an account in your browser and then verify it in person at your local post office.
I did have trouble with login.gov being broken by my blacklisting of sketchy third party domains. An official government website should _never_ require loading resources from any domain that resides under a commercial tld. If our legislators were even halfway competent they would completely ban such practices. Call it the REAL Network Security act or something.
I got my Google voice number in 2008. As far as I can remember it was not even publicly called Google voice yet. I still have the email which says
> Finally, we want to say thanks for signing up for the GrandCentral beta.
How can my phone number be an indicator of fraud but some number someone paid five bucks for to get an esim is not?
It is really irritating that organizations have started considering phone plans (voip vs prepaid vs postpaid) as fraud signals. This likely has something to do with information sharing agreements that each of the big wireless providers offer to sell your data. Really feels like yet another way for governments/companies to punish people who value privacy.