logoalt Hacker News

If you can't explain something in simple terms, you don't understand it (2017)

544 points • by sammatilda • today at 9:43 AM • 272 comments • view on HN

Comments

seanhunter • today at 1:01 PM

I think this idea is often misunderstood and used as an excuse by people who don’t want to make any effort to understand a complex concept and want to blame the results of their laziness on the explanation or the explainer.

There are things where you may be given an explanation in simple terms, but the concept requires effort on the part of the recipient of the explanation to really understand. I’ll give an example: compactness. Probably anyone who has done analysis is familiar with how this concept is usually taught. Typically how it goes is you do open and closed sets and then they hit you with “a set is compact if and only if every open cover has a finite subcover”. Now this definition is extremely profound but very dense and it’s highly non-obvious why that in particular is the property you want (a finite subcover for every open cover)[1], how you could go about proving that every possible open cover in a certain situation could have a finite subcover etc etc.

In this case it’s actually quite easy to give simple explanations of the separate parts of the definition (open and closed sets, what an open cover therefore means, what a finite subcover then is etc) but actually understanding the concept of compactness requires something above and beyond whatever explanation you are given: it requires the reader to get out pencil and paper, try out some sets, go for some walks, think about it in the bath etc.

You may get a really fantastic explanation in simple terms from someone who deeply understands the topic, but if you don’t put in the effort you’re not going to understand it yourself. That’s not the fault of the explanation. It’s not an easy concept to grasp so you have to climb the ladder of understanding. The explainer can’t do that for you.

[1] it took the mathematical community years to settle on this being the definition, so you shouldn’t expect to understand why this is the definition straight away.

➕ show 23 replies
mr_mitm • today at 12:33 PM

The article is just a bunch of quotes from Richard Feynman and John Gruber. There is little insight and I even think the article is misrepresenting the quotes.

Feynman said "if you can't explain it on a freshmen level". Leaving out that qualifier distorts the statement.

The other quote about the magnets is also overly reductive. Saying "I don't understand it in terms you're more familiar with" is not an admission that scientists as a group don't understand it at all.

You could go into what it means to understand something, but unfortunately the article isn't doing that.

➕ show 3 replies
tgv • today at 11:40 AM

Explain to what level? E.g some topics common here. How do you explain NP in simple terms? "Things that are hard to compute?" That's simple, but not much of an explanation. It leaves the listener with a practically useless definition. And how do you explain even something practical as Heartbleed or Rowhammer? Etc.

And then there's another barrier, of course: the audience. You may use simple terms, and tell a lengthy story, but some things are hard to understand. Relativity and Monty Hall come to mind. They can be explained in simple terms, but how many people get them? Probably just the ones that also understand a detailed explanation.

➕ show 11 replies
keeda • today at 7:22 PM

Whenever I see this I think to myself, “I can explain something in simple terms, but it will take more time than you have.”

Or in other words, “simple” does not imply ”short.”

However I’ve seen a lack of appreciation of this distinction play out in some exec meetings where “clarity” is prioritized above nuance. There is definitely great skill involved in crafting a message for an audience, and it’s critical to internalize that execs care about different things than you. But a minimum level of shared context is required before a discussion can fit into a 30 minute meeting. That’s why Feynman’s quote mentions “freshman level.”

I understand that execs deal with an avalanche of information and uncertainty, so clarity is a highly precious commodity. But I get the sense that “clarity” often means “just give me a simple answer”, which glosses over opportunities hidden in the nuance.

Frost1x • today at 11:49 AM

I don’t think this is true because it makes an assumption that reductionism is always possible, you can always distill every increasingly complexity into something less and less complex and maintain the overall behavior. I don’t think complexity is always reducible because sometimes the detailed nuance is absolutely critical to the distinction.

You may be able to take core ideas from something and distill them but when you have multiple interacting core ideas you may not necessarily be able to reduce them to simple terms. And almost always when you do there’s a big asterisk that the analogy has a lot of flaws.

➕ show 3 replies
kodebach • today at 7:34 PM

IMO understanding and explaining are two very different skills. I understand many topics, but I'm bad at explaining most of them, simply because I'm not good at explaining things, even mundane trivial things.

If your working as a teacher or professor like Feynman, then understanding and explaining may be equatable. In such a profession you are very practiced at explaining things and explaining something you understand should be easy. However, the "in simple terms" part also makes a crucial difference for explaining. "Simple" for what audience? Simple mean very different things for a five year old, a college freshman and something completely different again for a tradesperson. To explain things in simple terms you don't just need to understand the concept your explaining, you also have to understand what your audience already knows and understands and you must understand those concepts yourself too. I think the real skill in explaining is recognising and utilising this overlap between your knowledge and your audience's.

graemep • today at 11:31 AM

CS Lewis, an academic in a completely different field (literature: Professor of Medieval and Renaissance Literature at Oxford), said something very similar.

Being able to break things down into simple explanations (maybe many of them though?) is a sign of rigorous thinking. Not being able to do so (which seems common in some fields) is a sign of the opposite.

➕ show 1 reply
kjksf • today at 2:52 PM

Counterpoint by another famed physicist, Feynman: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q1lL-hXO27Q

Here journalist asks Feynman to explain why magnets attract and repel.

Instead of doing that Feynman spends 15 minutes explaining how the journalist doesn't have the foundation to understand the explanation.

At some point journalist will have to accept that things are the way they are instead of understanding why.

➕ show 1 reply
GMoromisato • today at 8:36 PM

I prefer a different test: If you can't make a quantitative prediction with better than 50% accuracy then you don't understand it.

I know people will argue that predicting is difference from understanding, but I don't think so. If you can't make somewhat accurate predictions (even at low precision) then what good is your knowledge? If I model lighting as an angry thunder god, that's certainly a simple explanation, but the fact that I can't make predictions means that I don't really understand lightning.

mikeleeorg • today at 7:12 PM

I've always considered understanding of a concept and being able to explain a concept as different skill sets. In many jobs, those two skill sets are combined and extremely useful when used together. But I've met some people who really do understand a concept, but for a variety of reasons, are not able to articulate it in simple terms.

➕ show 1 reply
sylphaenos • today at 7:32 PM

I like Early Retirement Extreme's take on this[1], which notes that you can identify 'pseudo-experts' who don't really understand the subject matter by their tendency to parrot a collection of rules or tips when asked to explain concepts.

- [1] https://earlyretirementextreme.com/experts-and-pseudo-expert... (2009)

munchbunny • today at 2:49 PM

In terms of teaching and understanding, I experience two types of simplicity. There's the type where you understand it at a surface level, so you repeat the simple terms. Then there's the type where you understand it at a level deep enough that you then understand how to simplify the complex web of concepts well enough for the situation in front of you, whether that's teaching a beginner, or making planning decisions.

The problem I experience is that it's often hard to tell which type someone is if you're not also an expert.

doginasuit • today at 2:12 PM

I think applying this idea broadly is at risk of underappreciating the challenges of communication. Feynman was A) An exceptional communicator and B) understood the topic in depth. Absorbing an idea through language depends on presentational structure. People who haven't mastered that can still understand something in depth.

I'd argue that the ability to explain something in simple terms proves that you understand it, but it is not the only proof and understanding doesn't depend on it.

That said, it is a useful heuristic to adopt. The challenge of explaining something is itself an opportunity to find a deeper understanding.

faangguyindia • today at 12:49 PM

"How does weight loss work?"

Calorie Deficit

"Does it work on all people?"

Yes, without a doubt.

"But humans are not bomb calorimeters."

Doesn't matter; minor differences in metabolism/absorption <<< calorie deficit.

Many people know X matters, Y matters, and Z matters, but very few are able to quantify how much X matters in relation to Y or Z.

This is why many people miss the forest for the trees.

➕ show 4 replies
riazrizvi • today at 6:03 PM

Also understanding comes in different forms. You can understand something conceptually, in which case you can re-express it with alternate, more familiar metaphors, like LLMs are trained to do. But you can also understand something via aligned embodied execution. Like you understand how to balance on a bicycle, where you're not aware of your hip movements but you do them.

Ppl diminish things when they have a narrow conceptual scope of them, so ppl can diminish understanding to conceptual understanding if they live in a highly dissociative way, meaning they live inside their head more than most. So it's safer to say we 'have an understanding of smg' implying less totality, because there are usually angles and scopes to the thing that are still beyond us.

amai • today at 1:18 PM

"If I could explain it to the average person, it wouldn't have been worth the Nobel Prize."

- Richard P. Feynman

➕ show 1 reply
mabunday • today at 10:55 AM

Everyone working on how Claude communicates would benefit from reading this.

➕ show 4 replies
signalToNose • today at 2:42 PM

A too simple explanation can cause all sorts of non experts make opinionaded assumptions that you then must deal with. Physics and medicine are fields where amateurs roam freely with opinions

➕ show 1 reply
jan_m_savage • today at 1:22 PM

Sometimes, the easiest, simplest way to explain something complex is in complex terms, because it is irreducible to simplest-possible explanation.

Complex explanations are either reducible, or they're not. Advanced mathematics requires years of compressed knowledge to explain something within itself.

Said differently, the same way you can't summarize any of the Nassim Taleb books (he takes pride in that). OR how watching a movie trailer and then the movie itself later, the experience gap will be very wide.

There are also complex topics that even lack a complex 'language for explanation'--for instance, quantum physics. The math works but not even the persons responsible for discovering it know why.

➕ show 1 reply
nstents • today at 2:33 PM

A student could not get the distributive property in a Math class. Just could not get it. Looking him in the eye I asked him about going to the store and buying a package with 5 pencils and 3 erasers...and how many of each you'd get if he bought 4 packages.

He got so angry when he realized how simple it was. Who knows how stupid he'd felt because no-one had explained it that way before?

It's a subtle relationship of meanings between conveyor and recipient. There are many minds out there that need a fourth or fifth different explanation.

kazinator • today at 5:06 PM

Roughly speaking, to understand something is to be familiar with the details of its description statically, and also all of the dynamic relationship of its parts.

All of that adds up to an encoding of a certain amount of information; if less information is used to explain it, then what is being described may be simpler, but doesn't match the real topic.

Sometimes what requires less information is a useful abstraction: something being explained contains details which are not relevant to a certain class to which it belongs. If you can't explain it in simpler terms, that could indicate that you only understand the instance very well, not the class.

tsoukase • today at 6:17 PM

You understand something when three sufficient prerequisites hold (example the second thermodynamic law):

- you can analyze it in simple blocks (order and entropy)

- these contain the deep fundamental intuition (it is a mathematical result of the law of large numbers and based on biblical distribution)

- you can apply it in any occasion (like ordered lego pieces get mixed up when shaken)

suzzer99 • today at 6:01 PM

When I first learned programming, I could explain it to a layperson because the things I learned were fresh in my mind. Now, I've internalized so many lessons that I don't even think about them consciously when I pick a paradigm to approach a problem. I have to really dig deep to think about why I'm making certain choices.

stdbrouw • today at 5:45 PM

A lot of folks in the comments seem a bit offended by this notion. Perhaps it works better the way David Graeber defined bullshit jobs: it’s a bs job if the people doing it think it is. So, try to explain something as simply as possible and if you fail, ask yourself: hmm, I wonder if I don’t really grasp the core insight here as well as I thought I did?

bsoles • today at 6:27 PM

This discounts the existence of a lot of neuro-divergent scientists, mathematicians, etc. who not only understand their fields, but also can vividly visualize thing in their minds. But explaining thing in simple ways may not be their forte.

➕ show 1 reply
erickhill • today at 4:29 PM

Isn't this sort of a mild continuation of Ludwig Wittgenstein's 1921 masterpiece: that thought, language, and reality share the exact same boundaries? Going back to brain cells from my college days, which are very old and crusty here. But the basic gist as I was taught it was if you can't say it or write it down, you can't really think it.

tropicalhunter • today at 1:59 PM

Found this on HN, last week I think, so I am sure a fair people know about it, but if you are messing with AI currently and agree with this line of thought, Jane Street put out a socratic-tutor skill that pseudo tries to break it down to this level and challenge those assumptions that make things flowery in business language, but often happen when we are taking the risks and overextending our technical competencies in order to impress clients. Maybe that is more telling of myself, but if you haven't, take it for a spin:

https://github.com/janestreet/agent_skills

amai • today at 1:16 PM

Any fool can build something complicated, the genius of a construction is in its simplicity.

- Sergei Korolev

➕ show 1 reply
someothherguyy • today at 11:00 AM

i have had plenty of people confidently explain things in a simple manner to me, but they have no idea about what they are talking about. humans and other entities do it online all day long.

➕ show 6 replies
kevsamuel • today at 4:22 PM

So, I sued to think that, but I now reached the point of my self where there are many things in my life that I understand but can't explain.

First, because "understanding" is not the one size fit all word people think it is.

E.G: you understand riding a bike, but none of your explanations, no matter how detailed (and they are going to suck), are going to lead someone to bike.

Second, because communicating requires a channel, usually a common vocabulary and a shared set of experiences, to be able to exchange on the topic.

E.G: there are things that are such internal or personalized experience there is not much to transmit to the other party like some things that happen during meditation.

And both points at the same time: what the experience of seen is to a blind. Communication is useless. Knowing more about it (the frequency of light for example) is not going to help.

Third, they are just things that "you know". "You understand". "They are perfectly clear to you". You didn't gain this understanding; it emerged, or it seems like it was already there. You can use the fruit of this understanding in a perfectly fluent way, and there is no doubt in your mind, plus your experience has always confirmed it.

And yet, you can share that.

So yes, while the initial idea is true for many things, I'll add this 3 nuances.

➕ show 2 replies
braiamp • today at 3:39 PM

I would like someone to explain magnetism on simple terms and not make assumptions about my knowledge and experience. Simple terms tend to be less accurate if kept short or overly verbose if trying for accuracy. At some point I have to build upon the knowledge that I presume you have and you have to make the effort to see what knowledge you need to call upon to make use of that knowledge. Feynman can't explain "magnetic force in terms of something else", therefore he doesn't understand quantum mechanics or magnetism, which is obviously absurd if we take the point of the article as true. The title seems more like an "aspirational" than actual statement of fact. Most things that would interest people can be explained in simple terms that satisfy most people, and explaining that not everything can be explained in simple terms is part of that.

bedane • today at 11:51 AM

still wrong

some thinking and understanding is conceptual, spatial, bound to mind-muscle, smells, etc.

a good chef understands the ingredients' cooking dynamics perfectly and may still have trouble putting this into words

lofri • today at 11:43 AM

As everything, I think it depends. When the topic under discussion is complex and requires extensive background knowledge, it’s still possible to explain it in simple terms but the risk is to oversimplify it and loose important details. The alternative would be to analyse every sub-topic until the required knowledge is reached, but that’s no longer explain something in simple terms, it’s just delaying the proper explanation to when the audience is prepared to tackle it.

rustyhancock • today at 11:22 AM

I think the caveat is, simple to me might not be simple to you.

You need to understand the subject to explain, and the audience you're explaining it to.

➕ show 1 reply
InsidiousWombat • today at 12:04 PM

I hate that stupid myth.

First, you can know topic intrinsically but just be bad at communication. The knowledge of the topic and communication skill to present it are two completely unrelated skills. The people that originally peddled it just couldn't imagine not being great at communication.

Second no, you can't explain complex term to someone that misses every basic piece of knowledge that is required to understand even the basics. That doesn't mean you don't understand it, that just means the topic is very complex.

You can simplify it (to the point of uselessness usually) so the other person have inlking what are implications but not, but they won't exactly know it.

➕ show 2 replies
RenRenJuan • today at 4:03 PM

This is right in "spirit" but wrong in practical, objective fact.

If you can't explain something to your self in terms you find simple and certainly true would be the correct standard.

It simply is neither the case that an unspecified listener is necessarily going to be able to understand even if you've attained it, nor is it the case that phenomena in general have the required simplicity.

The correct form of this specifies an adequately prepared interlocutor.

The community of these peers is how public knowledge advances, not what can be simply understood by the ignorant masses.

➕ show 1 reply
fortran77 • today at 7:44 PM

Feynman tried to prepare a freshman lecture on why spin-1/2 particles obey Fermi-Dirac statistics. He gave up and said, "That means we really don't understand it." At least he applied the rule to himself.

cedricddesigns • today at 11:47 AM

In french, we have this sentence that sums that idea pretty well : "Ce que l'on conçoit bien s'énonce clairement, et les mots pour le dire arrivent aisément" Nicolas Boileau (author)

➕ show 1 reply
croisillon • today at 12:58 PM

i think a big part of my non-programming IT work is pedagogy: many people build systems (even before AI) without being able to explain why/how they work

blindhippo • today at 5:44 PM

Some things, many things, require a large amount of built up knowledge and understanding to be even remotely capable of comprehending the idea in a meaningful way. There is an element of anti-intellectualism that drives people who think the world can be understood using an executive summary.

Even a simple explanation of quantum physics barely conveys a true understanding of the concepts underpinning the theory. Dunning-Kruger kicks in pretty hard as a result.

drewlanenga • today at 1:53 PM

This was the motivation behind xkcd's "Up Goer" and "Thing Explainer", wasn't it?

https://xkcd.com/1133/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thing_Explainer

FinnLobsien • today at 1:38 PM

This topic always brings up a predictable discussion:

But what about things that are actually so complicated they can’t possibly be explained simply? What if the simplification removes substance and makes the explanation inaccurate?

Valid concerns, but the point is more that deep understanding of anything requires understanding intermediate concepts it’s composed of, and then the things those are composed of.

pheewma • today at 8:32 PM

Love a blog post that just plops a bunch of quotes and then finishes with "kinda makes ya think, huh?" without any further exploration.

The comments I've perused that resonate with me the most center around: "for what purpose". Why does the person want to know. What will they do with this information. At what level of depth will they feel as if they now "understand" the concept.

A half-decent analogy is resolution. Sure, you can express the concept of a mountain with a 32x32 set of pixels, but what is the purpose of this "picture". Who's going to be looking at it and for what purpose. If a 9 year old asks you how the heart works, you can just say its a pump that drives blood through your circulatory system. But this is a woefully inadequate explanation for a medical student. At some point, reducing the resolution (reliance on already understood concepts/terminology) becomes an actual impediment to expressing the idea in a way that is useful to anyone at all (a 2x2 pixel arragnement).

There is something to be said about knowing your audience, communicating what is important to them, while also acknowledging that the nuance in any field is in the details and glossing over them or using non-academic terminology is necessarily lossy.

hinkley • today at 8:01 PM

<warms up Feynman sales pitch>

<clicks on link>

Oops.

So if Feynman is taken as a given, then does anyone here know of anyone in software who they would nominate to be our honorary Feynman? Hoare perhaps was, particularly in the 70’s, but he has passed which limits his utility. Liskov perhaps? Beck even?

jgeada • today at 5:37 PM

I can explain it in simple terms for you, but I can't understand it for you.

Almost every single time I've heard the "if you can't explain it simply" statement, what people were actually saying is that they wanted someone else to do the understanding for them. Not how it works, not how any of it works.

aristofun • today at 1:47 PM

Modern big it corp is everything opposite of the title. The more cumbersome and poorly documented system you create - the more job security you and your peers (hired to untangle the mess) have.

jwilliams • today at 6:05 PM

Snark aside: The article fails to explain _why_ in simple terms.

Sure. It’s a handy aphorism, but it’s not a universal truth.

figassis • today at 6:54 PM

Sure. Eli5 a black hole, without explaining the fundamentals.

gchamonlive • today at 1:14 PM

  What I cannot create, I do not understand.
We can, however create things we don't understand, so this is only a measure of the unknown, not of what's known.

🔗 View 36 more comments